Sanyi is not one list
The first question is what a passage classifies: writings, meanings of yi, or a Daoist path of interpretation. These uses have different evidence and purposes and need to be read in context.
Three uses of the term
Identify the cited text before interpreting its number three.
Lianshan, Guicang, Zhouyi
A Zhouli tradition names these three. Claims about the age and surviving form of the first two remain uncertain.
Simplicity, change, constancy
Yiwei and later commentators use this triad to explain different senses of yi.
Heaven, sage, mind
Zhonghe Ji connects these with principle, images, and the Dao. They are not three additional book titles.
How should the traditions be traced?
These interpretive traditions need not have replaced each other.
- 01Early bibliographical tradition
Three named Yi writings
The traditional Xia and Shang associations must be kept separate from evidence for extant texts.
- 02Later interpretation
Triads of meaning
Different authors use threefold language for different philosophical questions.
Books or ideas?
The object being classified changes.
Three Yi texts
- Meaning
- A classification of named writings.
- Focus
- Bibliography and transmission.
- Distinction
- Traditional attribution cannot reconstruct lost originals.
Three Yi meanings
- Meaning
- An interpretive scheme about yi.
- Focus
- Ideas rather than fascicles.
- Distinction
- Not a bibliography.
Where to go next
Decide whether the context is bibliographical or interpretive, then check the cited work. The contents of Lianshan and Guicang require separate textual research.
Names and variants
- Simplified
- 三易
- Traditional
- 三易
- Other names
- San Yi, Three Yi Traditions, Three Meanings of Yi
- Pinyin
- Sān yì
- English
- Sanyi (Three Yi)
Source material and earlier definitions
English textThe collected definitions and excerpts are available below1 section · 372 words
The book-list sense appears in the Zhouli, in the account of the Grand Diviner: Lianshan comes first, Guicang second, and Zhouyi third. Later tradition associates them with the Xia, Shang, and Zhou periods respectively. The source reports that Lianshan and Guicang were lost; descriptions of their first hexagrams, Gen and Kun, are traditional reconstructions rather than surviving complete early books. Zhouyi became the most widely transmitted member of the triad. The Zhouli also assigns each tradition eight basic trigrams and sixty-four derived hexagrams, while later commentators describe differences in the forms used for divination. These accounts should not be confused with proof that the lost books survive in a known original form.
A different use classifies three meanings of the word yi. Jianyi is ease or simplicity: the Yi can express a pattern without needless complexity. Bianyi is change: seasons, circumstances, and the figures and lines of divination do not remain fixed. Buyi is what does not change, described in the cited traditional texts as an enduring order of positions and relationships. The last meaning reflects the social and cosmological assumptions of its texts; it is not a modern claim that every hierarchy is permanent. The source connects these readings with the Yiwei and later explanations by Zheng Xuan, Kong Yingda, and Cheng Yi.
The Zhonghe Ji uses the same heading, Sanyi, for Tianyi, Shengyi, and Xinyi—heavenly Yi, sage's Yi, and Yi of the mind. In its exposition these concern principle, images, and the Dao or its practice. It links observation of changing qi and circumstances to the first, interpretation of hexagrams and lines to the second, and questions of human life and conduct to the third. This is an interpretive sequence, not another list of three Yi books.
The source also cites the Siku Quanshu Zongmu's explanation of the title Sanyi Dongji, where the three are associated with Fuxi, King Wen, and Confucius. Likewise, later texts attributed to the lost Lianshan and Guicang are not automatically accepted as authentic: the source notes objections to the transmitted Gu Sanfen Shu and records later disputes over whether copies still existed. In reading any occurrence of Sanyi, the immediate cited text determines whether the term classifies writings, meanings, modes of interpretation, or traditional figures.
References
- [1]Dictionary of Daoism