Gu Yi Kao Yuan and Debates on Yi Origins
The book challenges some Han and Song explanations and argues for a particular account of the sixty-four hexagrams and number systems. It is useful for Ming intellectual history even where its claims about remote antiquity remain unproved.
The Three Fascicles
The book's organization does not certify each historical conclusion.
Diagrams and order
A model of eight trigrams forming sixty-four hexagrams challenges a King Wen attribution.
Stalk numbers
A number theory differs from those of Liu Xin and Liu Mu.
Three Yi traditions
Lianshan, Guicang, and Zhouyi enter a larger argument about ancient transmission.
Book and Reception
A later evaluation cannot prove a prehistoric origin.
- 01Ming
An origin argument
The author connects diagrams, numbers, and three traditions.
- 02Qing bibliography
Siku Quanshu Zongmu
Its appraisal questions inherited authority while treating the book as one view.
- 03Later collections
Two transmission settings
Xu Daozang and Siku Quanshu preserved the work in distinct editorial contexts.
Argument and Evidence
Fuxi authorship is a later claim under scrutiny.
Ming interpretation
- Meaning
- A diagrammatic theory of hexagram origins.
- Focus
- Debate with Han and Song exegesis.
- Distinction
- Reasoning alone cannot date primordial composition.
Textual witnesses
- Meaning
- Editions and excavated materials for comparison.
- Focus
- Sequence, layers, and chronology.
- Distinction
- A partial resemblance cannot prove every origin claim.
Where to go next
Read the argument by fascicle, then compare Siku Quanshu Zongmu's reservations rather than treating a diagram as a historical record.
Names and variants
- Simplified
- 古易考原
- Traditional
- 古易考原
- Other names
- Study of the Origins of the Ancient Yi
- Pinyin
- Gǔ yì kǎo yuán
- English
- Gu Yi Kao Yuan
Source material and earlier definitions
English textThe collected definitions and excerpts are available below1 section · 264 words
The first fascicle treats Fuxi's trigrams and hexagrams. Instead of accepting a common account that Fuxi made eight trigrams and King Wen later doubled them into sixty-four hexagrams, the author makes each three-line base trigram the ground for eight six-line combinations. One of the eight becomes the principal or jing hexagram and seven become derivative or bie hexagrams. The book also disputes inherited square and circular ordering diagrams, so its theory concerns both authorship and arrangement.
The second fascicle develops an account of stalk-divination numbers and the Hetu. It treats fifty as a basic number and forty-nine as a number used in calculation, deriving an expanded total of ninety-nine by its own diagrammatic reasoning. These are the work's numerological claims, not a modern historical demonstration that Fuxi devised the figures. The third fascicle compares Lianshan, Guicang, and Zhouyi, the three Yi traditions associated with the Xia, Shang, and Zhou in later scholarship.
The study was included in Xu Daozang and Siku Quanshu. Siku Quanshu Zongmu questions whether the author's reconstruction has an ancient chain of transmission while still recognizing it as a distinct scholarly view. Its reception thus shows how later scholars evaluated a bold explanation of the Yi's beginnings without settling the prehistoric question.
The copied Chinese entry gives the Ming author's personal name in two damaged or inconsistent forms, and some hexagram names are corrupted. An exact author attribution or quotation should come from a checked edition. The entry also asserts a resemblance to an excavated Yi sequence; even if a particular ordering matches, that would not establish the entire origin theory.
References
- [1]《續道藏》